How to Choose Between the SAT and ACT: A Guide to Finding the Best Fit for You

By Dr. Fred ZhangWhen it comes to college admissions, students often face the challenge of choosing between the SAT and ACT. Both tests are accepted by nearly all colleges, making it difficult to decide which one to take. Since the changes made to the SAT in 2016, the two exams have become more similar than ever. However, there are still distinct differences in content and format. So, how do you determine which test will lead to the best result for you? Drawing from my experience as a 99th percentile scorer on both tests, I’ll provide you with a surefire way to figure out which exam suits you best.The Gold Standard for Deciding Between the SAT and ACTThere are enough differences between the two exams that it's not easy to predict in advance which one you'll perform better on. The method I’m about to share is the most reliable way to discover the test that will give you the best outcome.Once you’ve gone through this process, you won’t need to guess. You’ll have hard data to help you decide which exam to focus on for the highest possible score.What's the Method?The method is simple: Take both a full practice SAT and a full practice ACT.This approach is often referred to as the gold standard because it gives you the clearest insight into which test you’ll perform better on. You may have heard that practice tests are the best way to prepare for the SAT or ACT, but they also serve as a fantastic diagnostic tool to compare your strengths between the two exams.Who Should Use This Method?Taking two full-length practice tests is time-consuming, but it’s incredibly useful. It’s the best way to ensure you're putting your time and energy into the right test. Here’s when you should use this method:#1: You’re Studying for 40+ HoursIf you're planning to dedicate 40+ hours to studying for the SAT or ACT, you’ll want to make sure that you’re focusing your energy on the test that suits you best. On the other hand, if you only have 20 hours left to study, this method may not be worth the time investment.#2: You’re Willing to Invest Time and Energy in StudyingIf you're serious about getting the best possible score and are willing to put in the effort, then this method is essential. Taking both practice tests not only helps you decide which test to take but also gives you valuable practice that will benefit you in the long run.How Do I Find Out Whether I'm Better at the ACT or SAT?Follow these steps:Step 1: Take a Full Practice SAT and a Full Practice ACTFind real SAT and ACT practice tests (you can find free ones online). Take each test under real conditions: use a timer, calculator, and find a quiet, distraction-free space. Ideally, take each test on separate days so that you can be rested for both exams.Step 2: Convert Your ACT Score to an SAT ScoreOnce you've taken both tests, use an ACT-to-SAT conversion tool to compare scores. For example, if you score a 29 on the ACT, you can convert that score to its SAT equivalent using an online tool.Step 3: Compare Your Scores and Make the CallIf the difference between your scores is more than 100 points, the decision is clear: you are better at one test than the other. Colleges will reward your higher score, so go with the test you performed better on.If your scores are within 100 points of each other, then you don’t have a significant disadvantage on either test. In that case, you can choose to focus your efforts on whichever test you prefer.Choosing between the SAT and ACT doesn’t need to be a guessing game. With this method, you’ll have clear data to guide your decision, making your study time more effective.At Weil College Advising, we offer SAT and ACT prep to help you maximize your scores and prepare for the college admissions process. Reach out to us at info@weilcollegeadvising for more information and to get started today!